The following is an article from the book Uncle John’s Perpetually Pleasing Bathroom Reader.
When directors finish a movie and hate it (because the studio interfered or they’re embarrassed by it), they don’t want their names on it. So what do they do? Until a few years ago, orphaned films were credited to “Alan Smithee.”
THE MAN WHO WASN’T THERE
Until 1968, the Directors Guild of America required mainstream movie directors to use their real names on films, based on the concept that a director is the main creative force or “author” behind a film. (In the film world, this is called auteur theory— auteur is French for “author.”) The rule also prevented studios and producers from failing to credit a director that they didn’t get along with. But until 2000, the DGA had one exception to the rule: They allowed unhappy directors to use a pseudonym— the same pseudonym— Alan Smithee. Why “Alan Smithee”? DGA brass wanted a name that sounded generic or common (like Smith), but tweaked just a bit so that it wasn’t anybody’s actual name (like Smithee).
Directors now had a powerful tool at their disposal. If they could prove to the DGA that producers or a studio had taken away their creative control, they could un-credit themselves from a film and attribute it to “Alan Smithee.” The only stipulation: If they used the pseudonym, they could never publicly discuss having worked on the film in question or the fallout that ensued. Here are some films that were directed by “Alan Smithee”… and who really made them.
Movie: Death of a Gunfighter (1969)
Directors: Robert Totten, Don Siegel
Story: As the Western genre started to lose relevance, along came this movie, a Western about the end of the Wild West era as modern society encroaches, leaving behind a traditional, iron-fisted sheriff of a small dusty town, portrayed by veteran actor Richard Widmark. The shoot dragged on for almost a year, plagued by disagreements between Widmark and 32-year-old Totten, a director who had directed more than 40 episodes of TV Westerns like Gunsmoke and Bonanza. Widmark eventually won.