The French Chef Who Wrote a Misguided Thanksgiving Cookbook

A couple times already this year, we've discussed how Thanksgiving dinner is a celebration of American foods. That part of the feast flew over the head of one of the most famous French chefs ever. Auguste Escoffier wrote Le Guide Culinaire in 1903, which became a bible of sorts for French cooking. That's what he is most remembered for. But in 1911, he wrote Thanksgiving Cookbook as a newspaper supplement. That one is rarely mentioned these days.  

The book was intended to double as a guide for home cooks preparing a Thanksgiving meal and an intro to French cooking. Escoffier did include a suggested menu for a multi-course Thanksgiving meal. Strangely, though, it did not have any of the dishes we’d now associate with Thanksgiving—no turkey, no mashed or sweet potatoes, no stuffing, no gravy, no green beans or brussels sprouts, no squash of any kind, no cranberry sauce, and no pumpkin pie.

Instead, in the cookbook, Escoffier offered 12 separate recipes for rabbit, a chapter on ragouts that featured only mutton, recipes for tomato sauce and macaroni; “some new ways for preparing tomatoes” including “Tomatoes à la Americaine” (basically tomatoes sliced and sprinkled with salt, pepper, vinegar and oil); crawfish recipes and tips on making cream soups.

Yeah, tomatoes are American, but are usually out of season for most of the country by Thanksgiving. The story of how Escoffier totally misunderstood the American attitude toward French cooking for an American holiday is at Atlas Obscura.

(Image credit: Sunday American/Sarah Laskow)

We dish up more neat food posts at the Neatolicious blog

Newest 3
Newest 3 Comments

Usually, before the first frost we pick the green tomatoes and wrap them in newspaper and put them into a large paper grocery bag. They will slowly ripen over time and we have enjoyed wonderful ripe tomatoes well into February. My dad always grew way too many tomato plants but they never went to waste in our family. When I was expecting my 2nd child I craved tomatoes and ate a whole basketful in 1 day. I still can't believe I actually did that.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Strangely, we will have fresh garden tomatoes for Thanksgiving this year. The first killing frost was last week, so I picked the green tomatoes before nightfall. We have several that are ripe enough to serve today!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"The French Chef Who Wrote a Misguided Thanksgiving Cookbook"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More