The End of the Pronoun Whom

In standard English grammar, the pronoun who is used as a subject and whom as a direct or indirect object. Here's an example:

Who will decide to whom we will give the responsibility of carrying Alex's sedan chair today?

In this sentence, who is the subject and whom is the indirect object. It's a distinction that's easy to forget and increasingly people are. Megan Garber of The Atlantic writes that the proper use of whom is dying out:

Articles in Time magazine included 3,352 instances of whom in the 1930s, 1,492 in the 1990s, and 902 in the 2000s. And the lapse hasn’t been limited to literature or journalism. In 1984, after all, the Ghostbusters weren’t wondering, “Whom you gonna call?”

Whom, in other words, is doomed. As Mignon Fogarty, the host of the popular Grammar Girl podcast, told me: “I’d put my money on whombeing mostly gone in 50 to 100 years.”

Who is to blame? In part, the internet:

Technology seems to be speeding the demise. Online, on-screen, strict rules are systematically broken—for brevity’s sake, for clarity’s sake, and sometimes for the sake of ease or irony or fun. (Because LOL, amirite?!) What the Indiana University linguist Susan Herring refers to as “e‑grammar” is, she points out, a grammar only in the broadest sense of the word. In a context that can make whom seem almost aggressively retrograde, we err intentionally, breaking rules that are in some cases, Jack Lynch writes in his book The Lexicographer’s Dilemma, simply “prejudice representing itself as principle.” And the Internet, itself almost aggressively forward-looking, institutionalizes the errors. Dating sites talk about the people “who you match with.” Twitter offers its users a recommendations list titled “Who to Follow.”

Link -via David Thompson | Photo: greeblie

Should we retain the pronoun whom?





It matters to me because I had to learn proper grammar in school. Just like I learned about ethics, right and wrong, that voting for class president isn't a popularity contest or that politicians serve their voters' needs and desires, not their own selfish interests. hmmm Maybe some of these things can explain why there are sooo many angry people in the world? We were taught things that are obsolete and/or don't matter anymore, more's the pity.
grrr I'm going over to Icanhazcheezburger to mis-spell words for captions about animals.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
The funny thing I find about people making too big of a deal about the reduction of who & whom to a single word, is that it has happened in English before ... with those exact same words. Once upon a time, I came across an article that summed this up quite succinctly, but I wasn't able to find that article again. But as I understand it, whom replaced 4 or 5 words from Old English, condensing them into a single word. Whom replaced the accusative case hwone, the instrumental hwȳ & hwon (masculine and feminine), the dative case hwǣm, and possibly counting the genitive case hwæs (which also can become "whose"). I am by no means knowledgeable of Old English, and struggle enough with Modern English, so take that with a grain of sealt. But if someone complains why current generations are too lazy to learn the difference between the two words, maybe you could ask them why their generation was too lazy to learn the difference between 5 words.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Theres an modern to old English tanslator that provides even more options at
http://www.oldenglishtranslator.co.uk/

hwa Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun nominative masculine feminine
hwá Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun nominative masculine feminine
hwone Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun accusitive masculine feminine
hwæne Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun accusitive masculine feminine
hwæt Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun accusitive nominative neuter
hwæs Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun genitive
hwám Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun dative
hwæm Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun dative
hwy Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun instrumental
hwon Pronoun who what - interrogative pronoun instrument
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
They do seem to be spelling variations as you suggest; google "Old English pronoun who" for lots of complicated details! I wish I'd paid more attention grammar at school; its a fascinating subject :-)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 9 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"The End of the Pronoun Whom"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More