Will Fines Fix Companies?

Major corporations such as Facebook always get caught behaving badly. But for some reason, the best solution that we’ve come up with is to fine these corporations. But does it really fix the problem? Is it really the best punishments to hold them accountable?

...the Federal Trade Commission hit Facebook with a $5 billion fine this summer, an amount that, while large, will barely make a ding in its business. The $170 million fine the FTC and New York state recently hit Google’s YouTube with is almost laughable considering Google’s overall worth.
Even the $425 million Equifax settlement, which came out of the company’s exposure of some 147 million people’s personal information, promised victims the ability to claim a $125 check. Except too many people signed up, and the pot of money for those checks was just $31 million, coming out to about 21 cents per person.
Just one big bank executive went to jail after the 2008 financial crisis; financial institutions paid more than $300 billion in crisis-related fines, but collectively they made much more than that.

We can’t put companies in jail, as they are not people. While we can put the company’s executives behind bars, this happens only rarely. Thus, the main options nowadays are fines, but how well fines work is debatable.

But it’s not hopeless. Experts say there are ways to make firms do better, including stomping out the cultural and structural issues that cause problems in the first place, implementing close monitoring after something does go wrong, and making sure accountability mechanisms are in place where they can be for the people responsible.

Check out more of this topic at Vox.

(Image Credit: geralt/ Pixabay)

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

Simple: don't fine the companies. Fine the executives who run the companies. Half of their salary and all bonuses should do it. When the executives' personal money is at stake, they'll follow the laws.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Fines alone won't correct unethical behavior by companies unless they are HUGE. Otherwise the CEOs will just take fines into account when calculating profit and doing their dirty business. Any punishment will have to hit not only their bottom line, but their ability to do business. And, of course, any rules to guide businesses away from ill dealings must not have any loopholes.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Not until the fines become a hindrance. You can save/profit $7 million and only get fined $250k? How is that even a choice.
Here's a hint: If the companies stock shoots up the next day because investors thought the fine would be more then you aimed way too low on the fines.
The $5bn on Facebook and $11bn on google are getting there. Equifax's fine? not even close. The company reported revenue of $3.41 billion for 2018 so the 500 - 700m they *might* have to pay will hardly affect the year-end bonuses.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"Will Fines Fix Companies?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More