That's What SHE Said!

(YouTube link)

You've heard the joke plenty of times. Person A says something totally innocuous, but person B gives it an entirely different slant by responding with, "That's what SHE said!" The joke is most likely too old for the actual origin to ever be found, but we may now have the earliest recording of it, or a reasonable facsimile that means the same thing. It was a young Alfred Hitchcock, helping actress Joan Barry Anny Ondra through a screen test with sound in 1929. "Talkies" were brand new, and the switch from silent films was not simple.

As production for Hitchcock’s early thriller Blackmail began, his studio, British International Pictures, decided to convert it. While all of Hitchcock’s classic film techniques made the transition easily, Czech actress Anny Ondra’s accent didn’t.

Enter Barry. A veteran of silent films in the Twenties, Berry had a bubbly, merry voice that made her attractive to Hitchcock as a vocal stand-in for Ondra. In an early sound test, which the British Film Institute (BFI) shared on YouTube four years ago, Barry confesses herself to be “terribly frightened,” while “Hitch” puts her at ease with a series of racy jokes.   

And part of it was Hitchcock saying the line, “Stand in your place, otherwise it will not come out right—as the girl said to the soldier.” You can guarantee it wasn't the first time Hitchcock used that joke. It wouldn't have made it into any script of the era, but as a document on film, it's a classic. -via The Daily Dot

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

It appears you are right -I was using information from The Daily Dot (which is on the internet). I've corrected the name. Fooled me, because I don't find her voice or accent to be any problem. I'm sure the joke is older than the 20th century, in one form or another.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Worth mentioning: The video shows Hitchcock with Anny Ondra, not Joan Barry (not "Berry"). Ondra's voice was replaced live on set with Barry's. And Hitchcock's line is a variant on one — "said the actress to the bishop" — that's been around in Britain since the early 20th century:

All of this is pretty well known. You can find it on, you know, the Internet.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"That's What SHE Said!"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More