Power Without Status Makes People Mean

Why are pencil-pusher bureaucrats - like, for example, DMV workers - are often so mean? Researchers led by Nathanael J. Fast at Stanford Graduate School of Business have the answer:

A new study shows why interactions with DMV employees and other clerical workers can be so fraught, and why it can feel like they are picking on people who just want to register a car. The research, titled The Destructive Nature of Power Without Status, concludes that people in positions with power but low social status often use their authority to demean others.The lesson is not just that power corrupts, but that putting people in demeaning roles leads them to demean others. In other words, it's a real life reminder of the trope that "misery loves company."

The study used 213 undergraduate students in role play scenarios, simulating different combinations of power and status. The researchers told some students they were high-status "idea producers" and others they were low-level workers, and split them further into low- and high-power groups. The students were asked to assign their classmates tasks from a list including everything from "clap your hands 50 times" to "say 'I am filthy' five times." The students given high power but low status were significantly more likely to assign the most demeaning tasks than members of the other three groups. That "demonstrates that power liberates one to act on the negative emotions that result when one is being disrespected by others," says Stanford's Nir Halevy, one of the study's three authors.

Link | The study at Stanford GSB

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

I went to the DMV recently and the ladies there were all neutral-to-nice, EXCEPT to the customers who were being a pain in the butt. It was fun to watch.

"You have to wait in line, like everybody else."

She had a smile on her face, but here eyes were dead.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I think most of us knew this all ready..... and the study is pretty bogus in the sense it was an entirely artificial environment using the same group of people (students). Research into the background of workers at the DMV, TSA, Post Office etc. would be better.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
This makes me think of Sydney train guards. I was once with some friends who brought a friend who decided to drink on the train (which is illegal), and then ran off the train when he was caught. The train guards then proceeded to separate all the rest of us (who weren't drinking) on the train for individual interrogation on details of the drinking idiot, threatening us with charges of "obstruction of justice".
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"Power Without Status Makes People Mean"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More