"Should We Clone Neanderthals?"

That's the provocative title of an article in this month's Archaeology magazine exploring the scientific, legal, and ethical considerations involved. Extensive information about the Neanderthal genetic code is available, and the technologic problems can apparently be overcome. Questions remain about how the process might best be accomplished, and whether it should be done at all.
The Neanderthals broke away from the lineage of modern humans around 450,000 years ago... As different as Neanderthals were, they may not have been different enough to be considered a separate species.  "There are humans today who are more different from each other in phenotype [physical characteristics]," says John Hawks, a paleoanthropologist at the University of Wisconsin... Many of the differences between a Neanderthal clone and a modern human would be due to genetic changes our species has undergone since Neanderthals became extinct... Clones created from a genome that is more than 30,000 years old will not have immunity to a wide variety of diseases, some of which would likely be fatal. They will be lactose intolerant, have difficulty metabolizing alcohol, be prone to developing Alzheimer's disease, and maybe most importantly, will have brains different from modern people's...

"I think there would be no question that if you cloned a Neanderthal, that individual would be recognized as having human rights under the Constitution and international treaties," says Lori Andrews, a professor at Chicago-Kent College of Law. The law does not define what a human being is, but legal scholars are debating questions of human rights in cases involving genetic engineering...

Hawks believes the barriers to Neanderthal cloning will come down. "We are going to bring back the mammoth... the impetus against doing Neanderthal because it is too weird is going to go away." He doesn't think creating a Neanderthal clone is ethical science, but points out that there are always people who are willing to overlook the ethics. "In the end," Hawks says, "we are going to have a cloned Neanderthal, I'm just sure of it."

Much more at the link.  The image is a computer-assisted reconstruction of a Neanderthal child by a research team at the University of Zurich.

Previously on Neatorama: Misconceptions About Neanderthals, and Cavemen Did Have Compassion: They Cared for Disabled Children.

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

While nurture does play a significant role, genetics also influences brain development. Neandertals were after all a different species of human, and just as the brain of bonobo is different from that of a gorilla because of genetics, so to would the brain of a homo sapien be different from that of a Neanderthal. We can see this is skull impressions of Neanderthals, which shows that they tended to have a larger occipital lobe than us, and a small prefrontal cortex.

as for the tendency for European features, you must remember that Neanderthals lived in colder environments where sunlight was weaker. Lighter skin and hair was advantageous because it allowed for more vitamin D be produced by the skin when it was exposed to sunlight. Someone with very dark skin, especially a pregnant female and her baby, would be at a disadvantage in such an environment, especially since food was not as easy to come by as it is has been in the modern world.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
This is wrong. Recent biological analysis shows that neandertals were indeed fundamentally distinct from modern humans.

Please note that the information cited comes from a paleoarchaeologist, not a biologist, and the guy is only talking about biology here (i.e., not his field of expertise).
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
NC, you realise text books aren't written by scientists? It's true! And you don't need a background in science to teach it. Just in Education.

The more you know!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
""Should We Clone Neanderthals?""

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More