Library May Ban Children's Book to Comply with New Anti-Lead Law

Remember our post about the new Consumer Product Safety Act that will make it illegal to sell children's products unless they were tested for lead and phthalates?

Besides threatening to put local artisans and small businesses who can't afford the test (at $4,000 a pop), the law has another unintendend consequence: library may ban children's books in order to comply:

The Consumer Product Safety Act was passed by Congress Aug. 14 in reaction to findings that some toys imported from China contained dangerous levels of lead. President Bush signed the legislation, which includes stricter limits on lead levels in children's products.

The American Library Association said it fears the law has unintended consequences, and libraries may face the choice of closing their children's sections, banning children under the age of 12 or completing expensive lead testing for every book. [...]

This unintended consequence of the new law isn't the first to rear its head since Congress passed it. A flurry of complaints from second-hand retailers afraid of being bankrupted by the new requirements prompted the commission to release a clarification on Jan. 8 stating the law doesn't require all children's items to be tested.

However, it does make it illegal to distribute any children's item that exceeds the lead limits, said Consumer Product Safety Commission spokesman Joseph Martyak. Though libraries, schools, and thrift shops aren't required to test books for lead, they could face civil or criminal penalties if a book with an elevated lead level leaves its shelves. - Thanks Tiffany!

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

If they want us to get rid of those evil lead filled books, why not comply??? Ill simply get out my Brown shirt, Charlie Chaplain mustache & Red Armband with the white circle Swashtica on it & star burning Childerns copies of the Torah, Winnie the pooh, & lots of other Jewish & non-Jewish childrens books, while notifying the Local Press & inviting the press of a local book burning. As new & downloaded Copies of Mein Kampf & the Communist manifesto are OK & but old children's copies of the Torah & Winnie the pooh are not I cant get over the Irony of what these MORONS are doing with this new law. Or that I have seen it all somewhere before in newsreels of what went on in Germany Back in 1939.
It reminds me of that ever so timely quote, "Where one burns books, one eventually burns bodies.... "
It does however offer us the opportunity to use INCREDIBLY bad Taste & Sarcasm when complying ;^)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I recently bought a comic book (in France) and was surprised to see it printed in China instead of France or Belgium, 2 historic comic book printers countries.

Anything stopping China from attacking markets with social dumping seems fair to me.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
A good example of the unintended consequences of good intentions. Congress passed the law, and Bush signed it. Neither branch of government is without blame, but to give both credit, who would've thought? I tend to agree with Mikeeeey--lead may be the least of our worries, as we drink water infused with discarded medications recycled by our water plants, eat beef fed on who knows what besides growth hormones, snack on peanut butter crackers... Well, you get the drift!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"Library May Ban Children's Book to Comply with New Anti-Lead Law"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More