You’ve seen Dumbo, and you’ve heard the myth about elephants being afraid of mice, haven’t you? Mythbusters takes a look at what happens when an elephant encounters a mouse. No animals were harmed in this experiment. -via YesButNoButYes
You’ve seen Dumbo, and you’ve heard the myth about elephants being afraid of mice, haven’t you? Mythbusters takes a look at what happens when an elephant encounters a mouse. No animals were harmed in this experiment. -via YesButNoButYes
Not that the Mythbusters do everything right, but this time I think there's another explanation.
or, they may have a natural passion for not killing other animals that would never be able to harm them?
Here's a few
http://www.shopzilla.com/8B--Sunglasses_-_cat_id--10070000__keyword--bolle%20glacier%20glasses__kw--bolle%20glacier%20glasses__qcid--1861551
I'm not associated with that store, they just had a few.
Try it with a wild-type mouse and no human odor while setting the test site MUCH further in the distance, and I doubt the results would have been the same!
--TwoDragons
The sudden unexplained movement and the mouse's white fur contrasting the brown dirt would simply have startled the elephant enough to make it wary.
Not to mention that the "monofilament" (fishing wire) was clearly visible and seemed to be cutting across the track.
The Mythbusters don't know the meaning of the phrase "scientific method". All of their experiments have so many variables that aren't accounted for that almost all of their conclusions are questionable at best.
and as for twodragons theory, the albino mouse might have freaked them out, but i dont believe they have good eyesight, making it probably not matter too much
and also, as you can see those elephants are used to humans, probably in a preserve because at the end they just walked over to the mythbusters and crew, and let them pet them.. making the smell of humans obviously not bother them
I know of stranger things that happen in nature and have perfectly logical explanations that just aren't apparent right off.
I doubt it has anything to do with the contrast in colors...elephant's don't have very strong eye sight and from what I remember, most of it is centered around movement, not color. Not to say that using a brown mouse once would have been a bad idea.
Also, the fishing wire was not the problem. In the full episode, the elephant walks right through it in the control experiment.
These elephants are not wild, they are in captivity...one of the reasons they used these were that they were not trained like circus elephants but they were also not dangerous, like wild elephants. The scent of humans shouldn't have played that great a role since they have keepers in their habitat often....their food is from people.
"OH SHIT!DID MY DUNG JUST MOVED BY ITSELF!WHOAAA!"
i would be scared "shitless" it that would happen,no pun intended
In any event, these guys are my heroes.
For those who saw the whole episode, did they try the same experiment with other critters?
As to why, that's anyone's guess. They did not however confirm the myth that elephants are afraid of mice, they simply called it plausible, which is not stretching it too far I think, no matter of how unscientific it may be.
I can imagine that they will need to revisit this.
Consulting someone who specializes in Animal Behavior would be a good idea, too.
Love the show even if the two guys are Doofs. The babe makes up for it with pure class.
So I see two things that would need to be done to rectify the faulty experiment.
1. Replace white mouse with a natural colored (brown) mouse.
2. Use something small (mouse-sized) and white with a remote control to see how the elephants react to that.
I believe that the elephants would not react to a brown mouse & I believe they would react to anything that was not something naturally occurring in nature.