Brain Scan Shows Vegetative Patient Responding To Yes-or-No Questions

By John Farrier in Health on Feb 4, 2010 at 2:21 pm

When a conscious person answers a yes or no question, certain parts of the brain become active. A new medical study revealed that people thought to be in a vegetative state demonstrate the same brain response, even if they can’t express themselves:

In the current experiment, the researchers found that three other patients identified as vegetative showed similar responses. To open a channel of communication, they instructed one of them, the 29-year-old man, to associate thoughts about tennis with β€œyes” and thoughts about being in his house with β€œno.”

They then asked questions, repeating the procedure numerous times, switching the associations β€” tennis with yes, then with no β€” to make sure the patient was in fact making conscious choices. The researchers had previously tested the technique in healthy volunteers.

β€œWe asked basic biographical questions, like β€˜Is your father’s name Thomas?’ and β€˜Have you ever been to the United States?’ ” said Adrian M. Owen, a neuroscientist at the Medical Research Council in Cambridge, England, who developed the method and was a co-author of the paper. β€œWe then checked whether the answers were correct. They were.”

Video at the link.

Link via Popular Science | Image: New York Times

Previously on Neatorama:
Man Actually Conscious Throughout Two Decades of “Coma”
Is This Man Fully Alert and Communicating – or Not?


Email This Post
Tweet This Post 
Share This Post on Facebook

Tags: , ,


Neat stuff from the NeatoShop:


  1. dr.psilo
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 3:30 pm

    Have they tried this on a dead fish yet?

  2. Melphistopheles
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 4:43 pm

    Look at the photo. See those big empty areas in the middle? That’s tissue loss. Lots of tissue loss. When Terry Schaivo was finally allowed to die, they measured her brain, which had atrophied to I think 39 percent of it’s original size. Even if these people can be reached, which I doubt, what does that mean? Are we keeping them alive for the “benefit” of their families, but they are suffering?

  3. cola
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 5:14 pm

    Dr.psilo beat me to it.

  4. eni
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 7:02 pm

    @Melphistopheles: Well, if they can answer yes or no questions this way, we could simply ask them if they are suffering.

  5. ozoozol
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 7:29 pm

    Excellent. Being able to answer yes or no questions means a patient would be able to let others know their wishes about being kept on life support or allowed to die.

    At least, some would be able to communicate their wishes–I’m sure that brains atrophied to different degrees and in different regions would prevent communication.

  6. ted
    Feb 4th, 2010 at 7:49 pm

    What’s with all this fancy brain scanning? Couldn’t they just use a ouija board?

  7. edselpdx
    Feb 5th, 2010 at 12:08 pm

    If that’s me “communicating” at some point in the future, could someone please put a pillow over my face and put me out of my misery.


Keep track of the comments with Comment RSS

Don't Miss: New Stuff | Bestsellers | The Cute Store
                   Funny T-Shirts

Need a gift? Get unforgettable gifts for:
Geeks | Pranksters | Kids | Hipsters | Shutterbugs

Lijit Search

Old school? Bookmark us! RSS Feed Twitter Facebook Page