I'm not trying to pile on here but I am hoping the feedback might help the Neatorama crew for future Mystery Sales. I too received the dreaded Celebrity Duck, though mine actually turned out to be a pink flamingo. I understand the odds are pretty slim of receiving one of the super prizes, but I was also hoping for something with some sort of redeeming value. I would have loved a t-shirt as a consolation prize. I gave the duck to my wife, who in turn will be giving it to one of her 1st grade students as a classroom prize this year. Sadly I don't think I will be spending $16 again on another Mystery Sale. I certainly didn't have high hopes to begin with, yet somehow I still came away from the experience extremely disappointed.