In December of 2007, a newspaper photographer in Lewiston, Idaho, saw a sign painter adding a Christmas message to a storefront window. It was a nice seasonal scene, so he took a picture for the Lewiston Tribune. Other journalists that day reported on a wallet theft that was caught on a security camera. A still image showing the perpetrator ended up on front page, just below the sign painter. The two men looked alike, and they were wearing the same colorful jacket. And the sign painter's name was in the upper caption.
Who noticed the similarities in the two front page pictures? Pretty much everyone. It didn't actually fly over the heads of the newspaper copy editors, either, but it went to print before they could update the story. See the paper and read the story of the guy who made the front page twice at Now I Know. -via kottke, where you'll see a larger, readable image.
(Unrelated image credit: Michael Slaten)
Commenting on Neatorama will earn you NeatoPoints!