Anime Recommendations and Open Thread

(The Good, The Bad, and The Vicious t-shirt now on sale at the NeatoShop)

In February and again in June, I made anime watching recommendations and asked for them from Neatorama readers. We had great chats about anime. So let's do it again, shall we?

I learned about Knights of Sidonia from Richard Eisenbeis, Kotaku's anime critic. He calls it "a mecha anime with a realistic twist." Knights of Sidonia, which is remiscent of Battlestar Galactica, is the story of the remnant of the human race struggling to survive in an inter-generational war against genocidal aliens. It is a superb series that demonstrates thoughtful and thorough worldbuilding. Some of these elements are truly original--not rehashes of common tropes. In any science fiction series, that is a tremendous advantage.

In real history, Japan National Railways--the government agency which operated that nation's rail network--was privatized in 1987. In the series Rail Wars, this event never took place and the JNR is still in operation. The series, which you can watch on Crunchyroll, shows the adventures of four young high school trainees who are trying to secure permanent positions.

Now the story of people trying to get jobs at a government bureaucracy might not sound exciting, but it is when it's a quasi-military organization beset with terrorist attacks and conspiracies. Even if you're not a railroading junkie, you'll be impressed by the complexities of modern railroading that the characters find so fascinating.

As I've mentioned before, Girls und Panzer is by far my favorite anime series. It's a surreal and thrilling story set in a world in which fighting in World War II-vintage tanks is a high school sport for girls.

That 14-episode series ran from 2012-2013. During it, the characters have matches against schools which are stereotypes of belligerent nations of World War II. There is an American school, a British school, a Russian school, and a German school.

In one episode, the characters mention a successful match against Anzio Girls High School--an Italian school. They never describe it in detail, but only note that the main characters were victorious. A few weeks ago, we got to see that match in Girls und Panzer: Kore ga Hontou no Anzio-sen Desu, a 37-minute special episode. It's a funny and exciting episode that filled in a lot of the backstory for the series as well as told a new and fresh story.

These three series are either currently airing or very recently aired. But I also found two series from the 1990s that were excellent. The first is Photon: The Idiot Adventures, a 4-episode comedy from 1997. It's about a boy named Photon Earth who finds himself caught up in an interstellar struggle for power and love. Photon has supernatural powers far beyond what anyone suspects.

Birdy the Mighty is a 4-episode series from 1996. A teenager named Tsutomu is preparing for his entrance exams. He finds himself bodily possessed by a mysterious alien agent named Birdy, who is tasked with defeating a criminal conspiracy on Earth. Tsutomu must now join her in fighting underworld monsters. It's a fun, quick-moving story with an animation style that I can appreciate.

What anime do you enjoy? In the comments, share your recommendations and any other reflections you have on anime.

Newest 5
Newest 5 Comments

Crest of the Stars is only 90 minutes long--that's short enough to encourage me to check out.

I find that the 12-episode model is ideal for me. I don't want to commit to very long series these days.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Knights of Sidonia sounds interesting. My favorite space opera (and perhaps in my all time top 5 anime series) is Crest of the Stars. If Sidonia is even 1/10th as good as CotS, then it's worth a watch.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I've been watching Rail Wars. It's OK, but I find nothing to really write home about. Seems to be a bit slow with no overall conflict to tie everything together.

I loved Girls und Panzer! The models were fantastic. If you haven't heard of it, check out Arpeggio of Blue Steel, which uses WWII submarines in a sci-fi setting. And for more WWII goodness, KanColle is a card-based (WWII) fleet game that is getting an anime sometime next year. I've not played that game, but if it gets licensed in the US, I'm sure I'll watch it.

And to throw some titles into the mix:

Sabagebu is currently airing. Bunch of girls join a high-school survival club, using some nicely modeled Airsoft guns. It's hilarious.

Mitsudomoe is an older series. Can you laugh at potty humor, double ententes, situations taken out of context, with a dose of deliberate perversion? No matter how cute the visuals may may look, this is definitely not for children.

Kobato is also older. Not a comedy, but a supernatural romance. I found the anime so beautiful, I ordered (all 6) of the (translated) manga volumes from Amazon.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.

Email This Post to a Friend
"Anime Recommendations and Open Thread"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.


Success! Your email has been sent!

close window

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
Learn More