Amazonian Tribe's Language Has No Tenses, Numbers over Five

Anthropologist Pierre Pica has spent ten years studying the Munduruku tribe of the Brazilian Amazon region. Their language has no tenses, plural forms, or numbers greater than five. Pica described life in a society where quantification was largely unnecessary:

To get to the Munduruku, Pica had to wait for some locals to take him to their territory by canoe.

"How long did you wait?" I inquired.

"I waited quite a lot. But don't ask me how many days."

"So, was it a couple of days?" I suggested tentatively. A few seconds passed as he furrowed his brow: "It was about two weeks."

The more I pushed Pica for facts and figures, the more reluctant he was to provide them. "When I come back from Amazonia, I lose sense of time and sense of number, and perhaps sense of space." This inability to give me quantitative data was part of his culture shock. He had spent so long with people who can barely count that he had lost the ability to describe the world in terms of numbers.


The rest of the article describes at length how people understand numbers cross-culturally.

Link via The Presurfer | Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Why does this story remind me of the "discovery" of the Tassaday, a stone age tribe in the Philippines? Remember how authentic they turned out to be?

No numbers greater than five? Wow! How do they manage in the jungle with only half the usual supply of fingers and toes?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
"No numbers greater than five? Wow! How do they manage in the jungle with only half the usual supply of fingers and toes?"

The desired knowledge comes from -- get this -- reading the damned article.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Wes, I did read the damned article. I was being sarcastic.

I just find it hard to believe there are any more truly untouched tribes in the wilds of anywhere. Supposedly the Tasaday had no word for blue. A color they never encountered despite being able to see the sky. These people supposedly went undiscovered until 1970, living in a cave a three hour hike from town.

I am not surprised that there are cultures that see things differently. That is normal. Pick up a bible. ever wonder why 40 keeps showing in days of rain and years in the wilderness? Or Methusela living 900 years?
They were the preliterate middle easterners' descriptions of a "shiteload." But to not pick up on base ten?
Pierre Pica's reluctance to discuss specific facts and figures in the article almost screams "Kippendorf's Tribe" to me.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
In all fairness, I must admit, I do know of Pierre Pica's work, and the issue of numeracy and numerical perception is really quite interesting.

And the Munduruku have been living peacefully within Brazil since their last makor tribal wars in about 1800.

Maybe of the article linked originated somewhere besides that paragon of journalism, The Guardian, it would have been easier to buy
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Jason that's just the point- They don't have a calender or clock- they live in the here and now, with only general non-specified past beyond a few days and general non-specified future beyond a fwe days or just as many seasons. That is specific enough for them.

There is no beginnig, there is no end........
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
That's very interesting.

For whatever reason, this reminds me of how our brain is hardwired to overestimate angle of inclination, probably so we don't try to climb steep hills.

So, it seems that the ability to count more than 5 isn't particularly important in evolution, but the ability to discourage oneself from climbing steep hills was (yes, I know that's not how evolution works, so no hate mails, mmkay?)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 13 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"Amazonian Tribe's Language Has No Tenses, Numbers over Five"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More