"Spike the Potato" is a highly amusing game for any party. All that is needed is a single large potato, a number of paper cones, and some needles.
Actually, according to the above blurb, you also need glue, string, and cotton balls. But you could skip a lot of this and use darts. Add a few cocktails per guest, and you'll have a really swinging party! This amusement is from 1933. Link -Thanks, Lee!
LOLed at "swing the tuber"
one on each team, in turns, throws darts at the beer, if they miss they collect the darts and pass them to the next teammate, until they puncture the beer. whoever hit the can, then runs up finishes the now leaking beer, collects the darts and sets up another beer.
one beer for each person playing. Mix in beerpong when that gets tiring.
Totally made that up. Or did I?