What separate us humans from animals? Is it the ability to think? To use tools? Compassion?
Kate Douglas wrote a very intriguing article for New Scientist about the 6 "uniquely" human traits now found in animals.
For example, take morality:
A classic study in 1964 found that hungry rhesus monkeys would not take food they had been offered if doing so meant that another monkey received an electric shock. The same is true of rats. Does this indicate nascent morality? For decades, we have preferred to find alternative explanations, but recently ethologist Marc Bekoff from the University of Colorado at Boulder has championed the view that humans are not the only moral species. He argues that morality is common in social mammals, and that during play they learn the rights and wrongs of social interaction, the "moral norms that can then be extended to other situations such as sharing food, defending resources, grooming and giving care".
Not convincing enough? How about emotion:
Emotions allow us to bond with others, regulate our social interactions and make it possible to behave flexibly in different situations. We are not the only animals that need to do these things, so why should we be the only ones with emotions? There are many examples of apparent emotional behaviour in other animals.
Elephants caring for a crippled herd member seem to show empathy. A funeral ritual performed by magpies suggests grief. Was it spite that led a male baboon called Nick to take revenge on a rival by urinating on her? Divers who freed a humpback whale caught in a crab line describe its reaction as one of gratitude. Then there's the excited dance chimps perform when faced with a waterfall – it looks distinctly awe-inspired. These days, few doubt that animals have emotions, but whether they feel these consciously, as we do, is open to debate.
Link | See also a video round-up of animals with "human" abilities, compiled by Sandrine Ceurstemont for NS - via popurls
Anyone that has ever had a dog, cat, horse, or any pet really, would probably agree that duh, of course animals have personality.
I agree with a lot of the article, but we still need to be cautious in assigning emotions to animals based on behavior. We tend to see what we want to see.
Um. Wot? Doesn't it just mean that they're social animals that are used to living in groups and instinctually avoid doing things that harm the group?
Way to project and anthropomorphize, science! Gotta keep those funding grants rolling in.
Altruism in animals doesn't necessarily equate to morality.
Seeing as rhesus monkeys are such social animals, they tend to be strongly motivated to look out for the wellbeing of the group. A rhesus monkey that is only out for him/herself is more likely to be shunned by the group for not contributing and would therefore be less likely to survive in the wild.
This behaviour is likely to be an evolutionary behavioural adaption.
http://www.livescience.com/bestimg/index.php?url=&cat=gayanimals
That description fits humans too.
Anthropomorphism is a perfectly respectable way to view the behaviour of animals that are closely related to humans. Chimpanzees share 97% of our genes -- it makes less sense not to assign human-like characteristics to their behaviour.
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/03/animal-minds/virginia-morell-text
There are a lot of theories of morality out there by well respected scientists/anthropoligists/philosophers/theorists, yet they all have limitations. It's hard to define morality in animals when we don't yet entirely understand morlaity in humans.
WOW. It's almost like that kind of thinking has started wars among HUMANS.
Hmmm.
I do not agree with that. You can say the same about humans too. We do not know whether the other human has feelings or, not we just presume its existence. We know animals have a brain and an advanced nerve system, they react to pain as we do. There is no reason to assume that they do not feel as we do.
Back at the university we were taught by the lecturer about cats in animal testing. They implanted microchips and various instruments into their brains with which they could discover that they actually had dreams!