Kissing Cousins as a Reproductive Strategy: Does Marrying Your Cousin Give You an Evolutionary Advantage?

Researchers at the deCODE Genetics company in Iceland combed through more than 150 years of data and found that "kissing cousins" produce more children and grandchildren than unrelated couples:

For women born between 1925 and 1949, with mates related at the degree of third cousins, the average number of children and grandchildren were 3.27 and 6.64, compared with 2.45 and 4.86 for those with mates who were eighth cousins, or more distantly related.

"These are counterintuitive, almost dislikable results," said Dr. Kari Stefansson, senior author of the paper on the study.

Dislikable, because our intuition is that the more closely related you are to your mate, the higher the chances of passing along the unfortunate traits so often associated with inbreeding.

Scientists are surmising that marrying your third cousin may actually be the best biological strategy for reproduction:

Now, many gene experts are scratching their heads while trying to explain the biological mechanism behind these results.

According to Stefansson, the reason that related couples were more biologically successful may be because these couples have "just right" genes when combined — not too similar, but not too dissimilar, either. [...]

"The take-home message is that ... we, as a society of [the] 21st century, have basically ruled against the marriages of closely related couples, because we do not look at it as desirable that closely related people have children," Stefansson said. "But in spite of the fact that bringing together two alleles of a recessive trait may be bad, there is clearly some biological wisdom in the union of relatively closely related people."

Link | Scientific American article - via 3quarksdaily, thanks Marilyn Terrell!


I'm not sure if quantity over quality is such a good thing in this day and age. Infant mortality if pretty low in the Western world, so having lots of kids as an insurance policy seems like overkill. Especially if you're going to be passing on those undesirable traits to lots and lots of inbred babies.

Not that third cousins are that close, anyway. You'd have to share a great-great-grandparent with the other person. Much of the rest of the world marries closer cousins than that!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I wonder how they seperated cause from effect in this.[1]

Might it not be possible that the sort of family who has lots of kids is also the sort of family that intermarries? (I'm not going to insert a comment about rednecks here, 'cos being British I don't know enough about it!)

[1] Actually I wonder this about almost all the research I hear these days.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
The study sounds like it would be susceptible to a LOT of cross-correlation error risk. It's difficult to separate exactly what causes what -- Here's an example: Do these "kissing cousins" also tend to have lower levels of income or lower levels of education? I'm betting they might. Then you are in a quandary -- are they poor because they are stupid? Or have lots of kids because they are i---educated (and maybe had more time)? Or married their cousin because their grandparents and great-grandparents each had lots of kids and thus the odds of them being in a "high cousin area" is higher? Or are poor because they have lots of kids? It goes on and on.... Just because two factors have positive correlation (when one happens, the other often does as well) doesn't imply causality in one direction or the other. People who smoke tend to drink more and vice versa, but that doesn't imply that nicotine increases the appetite for alcohol...
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
mindpimp: there is no evidence to suggest that sleeping with your second or third cousin increases genetic problems. medically there is very little wrong with having a kid with your first cousin. the only problem is a social issue, and different societies accept different things. There is a group called C.U.D.D.L.E. that is trying to legalize marrying your first cousin in all fifty states. (http://www.cousincouples.com/ for more info)

enjoy :-)

(I know way too much trivia)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I think marrying a first cousin could cause really complicated issues, like divorce. You'd still see each other (I assume) because you're still family... I feel its an awkward situation that would just get more awkward (partially because of already instilled views but also human nature...)
And I agree that more kids does not necessarily mean a better anything. It's an interesting trend but anything the researchers think it may indicate is pure speculation because there are too many variables, by family, region, country, culture, etc.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I bet there were lot of kissing cousins in the age of early man...
Inbreeding worked out just fine.
Not that I support it... My cousins are ugly.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
The Arabs have been known to do this since ancient times - it's called ??? ??? (bint 'amee) which means "the daughter of my uncle"

Back in the day, when the Arabs primarily lived in familial tribes in the desert - patriarchs would try to marry their sons to the daughters of their brothers. In doing this, they would expand their own tribe and prevent other tribes from taking away their women.

This has been adopted into the culture and it's not uncommon or taboo for Arabs to marry their first cousins.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 10 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"Kissing Cousins as a Reproductive Strategy: Does Marrying Your Cousin Give You an Evolutionary Advantage?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More