Forgotten Cremains of Oregon's Mentally Ill









Eva York died in a bathtub in 1896 at the Oregon Asylum for the Insane. After an inquest, which absolved the hospital staff of any blame, no one claimed her corpse, so she was buried in the asylum cemetery and forgotten.Eighteen years later Eva’s remains were exhumed, cremated, placed in a copper urn and forgotten all over again. Today the corroding canister containing her ashes sits on a plain pine shelf in what’s called the “Cremains Room” at the 122-year-old Salem institution, now known as the Oregon State Hospital.

In 1913 -1914 the state of Oregon decided that dead inmates were taking up too much real estate and their bodies were exhumed, cremated and put into these copper canisters. The containers were labeled but the paper labels degraded over the years and the identities of most of those cremated remains are forgotten. David Maisel took a series of photographs of the urns, now made into a book.

Link

This photographer has put together a coffee-table book full of pictures of the urns of the dead, forgotten inmates of a psychiatric institution. Is there anything that consumerists won't exploit for profit? I don't understand. Is it because they've been forgotten that their dignity is unimportant? Or is it because they were insane?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
If I had the tools, metalworking knowledge and the permission I'd open all those copper cans, place the ashes in a single container then use the copper to make bronze for a memorial statue. The ashes would be placed in a granite base with an inscription describing who these forgotten people once were. The statue made with copper from the urns would be a very detailed representation of a weary and downcast person sitting in a chair, shoulders sagging, like they were waiting to get out of the chair and walk away. I'd place it so the person was facing toward the way out of the hospital, looking out toward the road they'd take to go out into the world beyond.

Now you know I said it would be a very detailed statue of a person, right? I'd make it as realistic as possible, except for one detail...

The person would have no face.

I think it would be a fitting memorial for people who really ought to have one after all this time and it would be in keeping with what Grace Heckenberg said about all those unclaimed remains. I don't think they should be hidden away to stay eternally forgotten. A monument to acknowledge the shameful mishandling of so many deceased people (People, NOT just patients or cases or files or numbers!) who deserved the same respect and dignity as anyone else would serve as a stark reminder that something like this should never happen again.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@Cais:

So you don't think it's possible the photographer felt the same way you and I do about this? There's no chance he could have found a creative way to make people see how the state brought about such a tragic mess with poor planning and carelessness? :-/
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Doing nothing sounds like a good idea.
Actually, why not just get a can opener and rebury them somewhere in a mass grave? Make a little garden above, and have a memorial space. No need for faceless statues, just a plaque. Simple, refined.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I do feel the photographer felt deeply and the same as "dooflotchie" and Id love to see the State give permission to create a memorial for those lost souls. Being a care provider myself and someone who has known workers from Or.State Hospital, I know they'd feel the same. As much as I feel the cans, individually, are beautiful a memorial would be a reminder for all.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 8 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"Forgotten Cremains of Oregon's Mentally Ill"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More