Officials are investigating an incident where an air traffic controller brought his child to work and let him talk to pilots:
The probe comes after an audiotape caught the boy directing several pilots preparing for take-off last month.
In one exchange, the boy is heard saying: "JetBlue 171 contact departure." The pilot responds: "Over to departure JetBlue 171, awesome job."
The boy was apparently with his father - a certified air traffic controller. The adult is later heard saying with a laugh: "That's what you get, guys, when the kids are out of school."
In another exchange, the child says: "MS 4-0-3, contact departure," and then adds: "Adios, amigo." The pilot responds: "Adios, amigo." The pilots on the tape appear to be not concerned that a child is giving them instructions. (Source)
The pilots may not be concerned, but the Federal Aviation Administration and the National Air Traffic Controllers Association are:
"It is not indicative of the highest professional standards that controllers set for themselves and exceed each and every day in the advancement of aviation safety," association spokesman Doug Church said in the statement.
The air traffic controller was put on administrative leave by the FAA while it conducts the investigation. David Pascoe, the owner of liveatc.net which posts recording of air traffic control communications, said that the whole thing was blown out of proportion:
"Nobody in the aviation community felt like this was anything more than a noble thing, that a father would take his kid to work.
"And when you listen to any of the recordings, the situation in the tower is very controlled. There is no hint ... that anyone was too busy or anyone was interrupting the planes. The kid cleared two airplanes. It was very controlled and I don't think safety was compromised, nor should anyone be disciplined for this," said Pascoe, who is also a pilot.
The recording was from a network of receivers, he said, but couldn't reveal the source. The site, he said, exists for pilot education and sometimes other curious parties listen in. There was "absolutely no security threat" posed by the incident, he said.
What do you think? Unsafe or just over-reaction by the media?
Even if I found out a plane I was on received direction from a kid. I would assume the obvious: it was closely supervised, and the pilots receiving the instructions were aware and weighed the instruction accordingly.
Sure they probably shouldn't have done it, but not worth more than a "don't do it again, k?".
It's not like the FAA doesn't have more important things worry about or anything.
As for cuplability, the controller's boss is the dumb one for letting the guy bring the kid into the tower to begin with, let alone let him direct aircraft.
It was a good joke and a thrill for me, and no harm done. Of course that was a different time for airlines (flying in the cockpit?!).
I doubt that there is anything classified going on in the civilian ATC towers. Are random people allowed up there? I would sure hope not. But it does not seem likely that this guy's kid was a trained terrorist or anything.
Was it the most common sense thing to do? Probably not, but I bet it was a real treat for the kid, and that is pretty priceless in my book.
Clearing a plane for take-off is the best time to let a kid talk on the radio, because the plane is sitting still on the runway, with nothing threatening nearby.
No chance of a crash or mid-air collision.
And as usual the media coverage (including outside the US) was airing the news as if this event was a major safety concern, while indeed the take-off messages are not a very potentiallly dangerous situation, if you hear the radio communications, you can hear the pilots were really cheerful.