The Jedi Knights are Like the Taliban

So as I mentioned previously, there's an ongoing discussion among some political bloggers about the ideological affiliation of the Jedi. Are they libertarian, socialist, or centrist? The discussion has continued with further suggestions. Adam Serwer of The American Prospect seems to think (if I understand him correctly) that the Jedi had a problem with effective government. Jonathan Bernstein thinks that the struggles of the Jedi relate to decentralized governance. But Seth Masket offers this inflammatory view:

There are no great analogues for the Jedi in modern American society. They are a secretive, powerful religious sect contracted by the Republic to do vital governing tasks that include policing and diplomacy. Perhaps the Knights Templar were similar in some ways, although I don't think the Knights had any real authority within European society. Their jurisdiction was the Holy Land. In some ways, the Jedi sound more like the Taliban than anything we've got going in the U.S.

Link via reddit | Image: Lucasfilm

Which Star War movie had Jedi's do suicide bombing missions, cowardly kill numerous civilians, mark for death anyone that makes fun of their religion, and stone women for having the audacity of allowing themselves to be raped.

I must of missed that episode.

Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)

I think you slept through them all. From the Empire's view, that's all they every did.

Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)

Well they're obviously the Freemasons, the guys who really run the country :). Only they do it out in the open. Maybe they're the Stonecutters. "Who controls the British Crown, who keeps the metric system down...."

Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)

The Freemasons comparison isn't all that off. It could work. Except that the Freemasons are better dressers.

Get Updates In Your Inbox