We Do We Drive So Badly?

My daughter, the driving student, asked me why so few drivers use turn signals. I thought about it, and said it's because they derive no personal benefit from using them. Turn signals do not benefit the driver, only all the other drivers around them. It's like the group that could only eat with four-foot-long spoons: we only benefit when everyone acts unselfishly. Or obeys the law. That is an example of traffic psychology. Studies of the behavior of drivers show us that poor driving is caused by errors in perception and psychological quirks that make us notice bad driving in everyone but ourselves. The Guardian gives us ten examples, such as     

3. We forget that other drivers are people too …

When someone accidentally walks into us on the street or their shopping trolley bumps into ours, the usual reaction is to apologise and move on. But when driving, near misses are often met with instant anger – and in the most extreme cases, road rage. Research shows that drivers more readily dehumanise other drivers and pedestrians in ways they wouldn't when interacting in person. This loss of inhibition is similar to the way some of us behave in online environments.

4. … yet we behave more aggressively to those of 'lower status'

One interesting paradox is that even though we're prone to dehumanising other drivers, we still act according to social status. Decades of research shows that prolonged honking, tailgating, and other aggressive behaviours are more likely if the aggressor believes they are the more important driver. What's particularly interesting is that these judgements can be based simply on the vehicles involved, with no knowledge of the person behind the wheel: larger cars generally outrank smaller cars and newer cars trump older ones. Drivers of more expensive cars are also more likely to behave aggressively toward pedestrians.

Read the rest and see if you are reminded of anyone you know. Link  -via mental_floss


If you think there's no personal benefit to using a turn signal then you must be a truly terrible driver. The benefit is that other drivers around you know what you're going to do ahead of time and can act accordingly. Maybe you think there's no personal benefit to brake lights either?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  3 replies
Maybe you mis-typed or mis-spoke or something but in the post above it says you told your daughter people "derive no personal benefit from using" turn signals. Now you say it's safer to do so. So which is it?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
it also depends where you're driving, in Arkansas they are good about using their signal but don't check their blind spot or care if your passing at 70 in a 65 and they're only doing 60 they just pull out. now I live in KY and no one uses a signal, and they brake for no reason, most have a cigarette in one hand and a cell phone in the other, it's horrible and I drive for a living. also KY has 55 mph speed limits on most roads so you never know how fast people are going to drive, not much difference in the ticket between 70 and 80. never thought I'd miss driving the boring roads of NM
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
My Dad broke the habit of using turn signals to change lanes because long ago, in Houston rush hour traffic, drivers would intentionally cut you off if you signaled a lane change. Later, after moving to a different city, he had to teach himself to use turn signals again.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Human nature seems to include a very bad ability to estimate risks involved things with low probability but high costs. You could probably ask several of those people who don't use their turn signals, assuming they realize what they are doing, and some amount of them will acknowledge it could lessen their chances of an accident by some degree. But they will then have some rationalization for why that risk is not worth addressing, and there being more benefit to being lazy. Some people will not do more straightforward things, like wearing a seatbelt, unless threatened with fines. While it is possible for someone to be inconvenienced by something like a seatbelt or turn signal enough that they actually get more utility out of following an unsafe habit even with the risk of injury, most seem to be just misjudging risks.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
I'd also like people to turn on their headlights when it starts getting dark. Headlights are not just so you can see where you're going, they're so other drivers can see where you're going. At dusk this is especially important.

Slightly different problem: There are also people who don't realize their Daytime Running Lights aren't real headlights, and your taillights aren't on. I partly blame this on the modern always-glowing instrument cluster, though. It's much easier to mistake lights for being on because DRLs can also provide just enough light to see by.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
A shout out to those idiots who refuse to turn on their headlights in dense fog. People die every year from pulling out in front of a car they can't see coming. I have had to lower my window and listen for cars at an intersection many times. Headlights don't improve the drivers vision in the fog but they make your car at least twice as visible to other drivers.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
People that don't turn their lights on during rain, fog, dusk/dawn. Turn signals.
People texting and talking on their phones not paying attention to anything else. Speeding, driving too slow.
We have it all here and then some. The texting thing bothers me the most. At a stop light waiting to go, whatever... just keep looking up so you're still not sitting there when the light turns green. But put the frickin phones away when you are moving! I can't even count how many times I've spotted people, eyes turned down as they're texting and slowly drifting in to the other lane.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 14 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"We Do We Drive So Badly?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More