How Old is Too Old to Drive?

Yesterday, a man lost control of his car, which jumped the curb near an elementary school and hit 11 people, 9 of them school children.

That in itself is unfortunate, but the story gets prominent national attention because the driver, Preston Carter, is 100 years old:

Four of the children were seriously injured when Preston Carter backed his blue 1990 Cadillac into the victims, who were on their way to buy snacks from a vendor across the street from Main Street Elementary School, authorities said.

The victims ranged in age from 14 months to 48 years old. The children, some of whom attend the school, were in stable condition Wednesday evening, authorities said.

Carter, a Los Angeles resident who will turn 101 on Sept. 5, has a current driver's license and no history of traffic violations, the Department of Motor Vehicles said. The only restriction on his license, which is valid until 2013, is that he wear corrective lenses.

Ruben Vives and Robert J. Lopez of The Los Angeles Times report: Link (Photo: Jay L. Clendenin/LA Times)

Should There Be An Upper Age Limit for Driving?



In 2003, an 86-year-old man barreled into a crowd at a farmers market in Santa Monica, California, killing 10 people and injuring more than 60 others. In California, all drivers 70 years and older are required to pass vision and written test (but not driving test) every five years but an elderly's health condition could've deteriorated quickly in that time frame.

Depriving senior citizens of their ability to drive (and therefore depriving them of their independence), however, remains politically unpalatable.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I don't think there should be an age limit to drive, but after 65-70, they should be checking your eye sight and reflexes. This is no different than some states that have rules as to when and how teenagers can drive.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  2 replies
The problem in California is that if you don't have any violations or accidents on your record since your last license was issued, you can renew by mail or online, so no one can physically check your physical or mental condition. Doctors can recommend to the DMV that a license be revoked, but many of them don't even seem to think about it, or sympathize with their patients.

An 84-year old woman ran over my son in the crosswalk in front of his school not quite two years ago. Her license was valid and up to date. However, she hadn't driven in years, deferring to her husband, but his recent death had caused her to start driving again. The most horrifying thing I read in the police report was that the driver said she saw the car stopped at the crosswalk in the other direction and my son in the crosswalk, but she just kept going.

My son was very lucky. He was caught by the car and one leg was actually driven over, but nothing was broken. He has a couple of small, ugly scars. A smaller child might not have survived so well.

It also made me extremely angry because my own grandmother quit driving when she felt it was no longer safe. She did it in stages: first, she stopped driving on freeways; next, she stopped driving on highways (she lived in a mostly rural area) with higher speed limits; lastly, she quit driving at all, not even around the small town in which she lived. She stopped over ten years before she died, although her vision was excellent and her reflexes fairly good.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
There should be a point at which drivers should be re-tested, not automatically renew a license. It appears that would not have change the events of this story, but it's still an idea I've been in support of for years.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
My husband's grandfather actually turned in his license when he realized he no longer had the reflexes for driving. He was in his early 70's, and had a minor accident. The next day, he turned in his license. It had shaken him enough to question his ability to drive. He's 92 now, and hasn't regretted his choice.

Of course, not everyone will be self-aware enough to recognize it's time to hang it up.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  4 replies
Age-defined *anything* is a bad compromise, be it for drinking, voting, having sex, driving, military service, etc., as people mature and deteriorate at different ages. Though I realize there's no other easy way to set limits.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
Recently, I got stuck in traffic behind the most terrifying driver I've ever seen. She was swerving in and out of the lane, at one point driving completely in the oncoming traffic's lane. Her speed was erratic, she got herself stuck in traffic cones at one point, and she scared me senseless. She was a danger to herself, and to everyone around her. I thought she must be drunk or high, but when I got a look at her, I realized she was just very, very old, and potentially heavily medicated. I drove near her for as long as possible because for some reason I just wanted to watch her and make sure she was ok. We finally turned different directions, but I still think of her sometimes and wonder if she made it to her destination safely.

Since that day, I've worried about older drivers. I don't think there should be an age cutoff, since infirmities set in for different people at different times, but I would advocate for some kind of testing.

I've also joked that once my parents get old enough, I might put a "How's my driving?" bumper sticker on their cars with my number on it, because all I could think about when I saw that woman was how much I wanted to let her kids know what was going on, to let someone know that she wasn't safe.

My parents don't think that joke's particularly funny.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  2 replies
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 20 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"How Old is Too Old to Drive?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More