School Bans Soccer Balls and Hard Balls Because They're Too Dangerous

The schoolyard in Toronto, Canada, is safe again, thanks to the quick action of a school principal who has banned the dangerous weapon of ... soccer balls!

Before you deride the news as yet another example of school bureaucracy gone mad, won't you think of the children? They're an absolute terror when weaponized with hard balls:

Students at an east-end Toronto school are being told to leave their soccer balls — and other hard balls — at home.

The principal of Earl Beatty Public School banned the balls this week after a parent recently suffered a concussion from being hit in the head with a soccer ball.

The principal, Alicia Fernandez, banned hard balls, claiming they're dangerous. "Kids were coming in complaining of injury, or being scared," she said. [...]

Students can bring sponge or other soft balls to play with, but soccer balls, footballs, baseballs and even tennis balls are not allowed for safety reasons.

Link


Well I've been hit on the head by any number of footballs (it's football!) and I've headed any number of footballs and I've never suffered concusion from that. What kind of wuss parents do they have in Toronto?

Seriously it's elastic and full of air and weighs something like a pound. How could that cause concusion. It certainly isn't a hard ball.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
It's a soccer ball in a couple of countries, a football everywhere else. It doesn't matter, get over it. :P

It takes very little to give a concussion, the head impact from something like a soccer ball can cause the brain to take a pretty decent rebound inside your skull. It's highly unlikely to be lethal though, even for a kid.

That doesn't mean balls should be banned in schools though, it means the parent should be paying attention to his/her surrounding when on/near the field, just like they teach the kids to do. (I remember getting scared out of my wits in jr high with horror stories about a kid scalped by a discus).
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I'm surprised Toronto did this...it is so un-Canadian. Then again the Ontario school board is being very harsh this year. Just this year at my high school they banned most foods and drinks and created a new "healthier" menu. Also bake sales have been outlawed.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I quit baseball quite young because I was terrified of the kids who were old enough to throw hard but had no control. I saw no injuries in the first two years of my son's leagues when they used a softer ball but two serious injuries after they moved to the standard hard ball. Once the kids develop skills to handle a hard hit ball I can see using a harder ball but watch a 10-13 year old when they get a hot grounder. They will often try to catch it to the side rather than getting their body in front of it. If you love baseball you should want these kids to develop skills rather than fear. Same for soccer. Soft balls build confidence.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
They should ban the ground. That's what hurts you when you fall. I'm serious. The ground kills and injures people all the time, and nobody does anything about it, not even in England.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
So, this would imply that when I was a lad, and the school had us play a "game" called "bombardment", where opposing teams hurl volleyballs at each other with the express intent of hitting them, they were, in fact, enacting a sinister plot to get a wee bit of attrition? Those murderous nuns...
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I approve of this and happy that Canada is protecting their young. In a few generations, they'll be completely devoid of testosterone and scared of their own shadow. Then my grandkids can take over the entire place with a harsh word and sharp stick.

They'll rename the place Wolfland, which will go down well with the Greens and animal-first people.

And thanks to Global Warming, by this time the winter will be less severe.

Go Canada! (for now)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
about the only thing i can think of is: are you freakin' kidding me?! i mean, sure, kids can get hurt in PE or any type of sport. there's no such thing as a risk-free sport, period. but how many millions of kids have survived North American public schools just fine for well over a hundred years?? it's completely ridiculous!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
In all seriousness this is an indiction of how screwed up public bodies have become.

Where I work whenever an accident occurs somebody has to fill in an accident assesment form. One of the questions is "What should be done to prevent similar accidents in future?".

Note that it doesn't say "Should any thing be done...." or "Could anything be done..." it starts from the assumption that not only can something be done, but it must be done. And why? Because the organisation are trying to cover their own butts.

Can you imagine if the motor vehicle didn't already exist and somebody invented it today? It would never make it to the roads because of all the risk assesments that would have to be carried out.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Ditto #12.
I've been hit right in the face with glasses on by a soccer ball kicked at full speed.
Hurt like hell and made my cheek and brow swell up where my glasses dug in to my head, but other than that... nothing. No bruising after the swelling went down or anything.

Might as well just put kids in to their own private bubbles.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Honestly, the hysteria in the article and these comments is bizarre. I mean, "My husband freaked right out. He thought, this is absolutely insane." This woman clearly has no idea what "insane" means.

Apparently, the school has a very small yard, a wide variety of ages represented amongst pupils ranging from Kindergarten to grade 8 and there have a been a few injuries. The school has banned pupils from bringing their own "hard" balls in *temporarily* while a solution can be found.

Maybe this is just a principal that, whilst appearing a little over-cautious is simply taking a sensible step to prevent further injuries in the face of complaints from parents. Rather than an encroachment on the kids' human rights to life, liberty and to injure themselves by the health and safety Nazis.

Does no-one (skim) read to the end of an article anymore? What am I saying? Of course not. This is the internet.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
DuaneP they fear because they think it hurts. Kids will never develop the skill to field a hard hit ball when all they see are the those soft cover balls, they do not travel at the same speeds. What they need is something that is highly annoying to teach them to field properly, like taking ground balls in front of a thorn bush and then having to get the ones they miss.

Also soccer balls are not really any harder than a standard kick ball and I do not know what you replace a tennis ball with that would work.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Well the last time I got threatened in Sheffield it was with a cricket bat and a pickaxe haft. Have the dee dars gone soft these days. Threatening people with a football indeed. You'd get laughed out of Manc for that sort of behaviour.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 20 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"School Bans Soccer Balls and Hard Balls Because They're Too Dangerous"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More