Why do We Get Tip of the Tongue Moments?

We've all experienced the tip of the tongue moment where we wanted to say something but just couldn't remember the word. But what causes this momentary lapses in vocabulary?

Psychologist Jennie Pyers of Wellesley College in Massachusetts compared billinguals, monolinguals and people who are fluent in sign language to - what is that darned word ... elucidate - the possible cause of this phenomenon:

To provoke tip-of-the-tongue moments, the researchers showed the bilinguals, as well as a control group of 22 English monolinguals, pictures of dozens of different objects and challenged the volunteers to name them in 30 seconds. The viewed objects – which included axes, weathervanes, gyroscopes, nooses and metronomes – were obscure enough to elicit tip-of-the-tongue experiences in all but one participant.

As with previous experiments, monolinguals had fewer tip-of-the-tongue experiences than bilinguals, about 7 words versus 12, out of a total of 52 – though Pyers' team counted only instances where the volunteer knew the word.

However, Spanish bilinguals experienced roughly the same number of tip-of-the-tongues as sign language bilinguals. This rules out the possibility that similar-sounding words compete for our brain's attention in tip-of-the-tongue experiences.

More likely, tip-of-the-tongue experiences occur when we're trying to recall rarely used words, Pyers says.

"People often have tip of the tongue experiences for proper names, again because we don't use them very frequently," she adds.

Link


I have this problem quite a lot, but I do I know that I am very much a visual thinker. My auditory memory is quite weak, and I have extreme difficulty remembering verbal information as opposed to it being read.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
"More likely, tip-of-the-tongue experiences occur when we’re trying to recall rarely used words, Pyers says.

Is it me, or is that earth-shattering? The conclusion of this study was that people have trouble remembering words that they rarely use?

Where are they handing out this grant money?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
or, they were on the drug Topamax.

seriously. even after a month on that med i had serious language and calculation issues, so bad it threatened my job. it wasn't doing what it was supposed to be doing, anyway, so i went off it (unfortunately, you have to ramp down from full dose or you get seizures. ausome!)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
In other Earth-shattering news:

Cars run on a substance called gasoline!
Some people can glide across frozen water, also known as ice, by wearing a blade-type apparatus on their shoes!
Adam Lambert is gay!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Since when is an axe or a noose "obscure"?

And in defense of studies from the Department of Obvious: common sense answers/presumptions don't always play out as we'd expect. This is why we do experiments to get evidence to support (or not) what we suspect is happening. You also ferret out other possible causes of the same effect.

If the study had provided the opposite conclusion, it would not seem so stupidly obvious. And if done correctly, the researchers weren't going into it expecting to come out with the stupidly obvious answer-- they gathered data, which they interpreted into the stated conclusion, which is backed by their research... which is more than anyone saying "duh" could point to for proof of their own.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Actually if you read the study, they found out a lot of interesting things, like the difference between presque vu of bilingual and monolingual speakers.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
The article is clearly too simple, much more is known about this "problem"...with names...not so much that we don't use them often, but at times they belong to one unit only: Addis Ababa, Daar es Salaam...confuse the two always. Also one can often say..."missing the word"...but I'm close, it's got 4 letters and an "o"...Oh you mean "porn"?...finally...but there is so much more...if one forgets "alternative" for a while and tells the listener, its a word that means choices of different means or venues...often the listener will have a lot of trouble coming up with it.
As an individual who controls 8 languages verbally, I can vouch that this factor is irrelevant.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Commenting is closed.
Click here to access all of this post's 11 comments






Email This Post to a Friend
"Why do We Get Tip of the Tongue Moments?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More