Traffic Jams are Caused by ... Too Many Cars on the Road!

This is a familiar experience for most of us: getting stuck in a traffic jam only to find out later that there is no obvious cause (like accident, construction work or bottleneck).

Well, Japanese scientist Yuki Sugiyama of Nagoya University has finally found the answer: the traffic jam is caused by ... too many cars!

In the New Journal of Physics a study by his group explains why we're occasionally caught in jams for no obvious reason.

The real origin of the snarl up often has nothing to do with obvious obstructions such as accidents or construction work but is simply the result of there being too many cars.

The team discovered the importance of traffic density by applying techniques to model the movements of lots of particles to real-life moving traffic. The research shows that even tiny fluctuations in car-road density cause a chain reaction which can lead to a jam.

The team also studied cars driving around a circular track with a circumference of 230m. They put 22 cars on the road and asked the drivers to go steadily at 30km/h (19mph) around the track. While the flow was initially free, the effect of a driver altering his speed reverberated around the track and led to brief standstills.

Prof Sugiyama says, "Although the emerging jam in our experiment is small, its behaviour is not different from large ones on highways. When a large number of vehicles, beyond the road capacity, are successively injected into the road, the density exceeds the critical value and the free flow state becomes unstable."

Link

Update 3/22/08 - Here's a video clip that illustrates what happened:



[YouTube Link] - Thanks Christophe!

yet another waste of time, money, and resources. i work in the traffic center for AM commute at WHIO and i could tell you that accidents and backups are caused by people not driving the speed limit, and not taking into consideration the current weather conditions. then, because people don't obey the law, they end up behind someone who IS going the speed limit and slam on their breaks. the person behind them then slams on their breaks, and so on. moral of the story: drive the speed limit and allow one car length per 10mph between you and the person in front of you, ESPECIALLY on the highway. i know it's hard to allow so much space, but it will only benefit you. it allows you to slam on your breaks if the situation presents itself, it allows other vehicles to maneuver around you and others, and it's just more safe. PLEASE! we hate reporting fatalities... we just had one this morning, and it's very unpleasant. wear your seatbelt and drive safe, everyone!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I am still believe it is caused by stupid drivers and poor traffic light synchronization. Here you get the idiots who wait until the very last second to get over on a lane closure then you have the idiots who go though a green or yellow and stop in the middle of the intersection and then the light turns red continually stopping the cross traffic causing even more of a backup. I know many lights which are completely out of sync which causes many of the problems.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I find it so funny when there are all these people at shopping centers who can't find a parking space ANYWHERE, while the very top floor is completely deserted.
And I had no IDEA that too many cars caused traffic jams.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
And thus we've just witnessed the "after thought" or "common sense" effect with responses to this post. The goal of science is to make the subjective objective so that people can say for sure "traffic jams result first and foremost from too much cars" over the highly opinionated common sense " traffic is caused by too many cars because I observed it over the years in my day to day experience, duh." While person B says "well in my experience it's braking and stupid driving." Had the results said braking and stupid driving, people would be like "I knew that! What a waste of money. Anyone could have come to that conclusion." Chah right ... This type of research is not a waste nor is it just reinforcing the obvious. Now that we know for sure that it is too much cars, we can look for better solutions to alleviate traffic.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
ObsidianPunk is right. Give them some credit--99% of what they do and know isn't apparent to you or me. What we do see can seem obvious or simple because someone along the line simplified it for general consumption.

And just because it all seems simple doesn't mean it is. This is true in any job that requires any knowledge or skill. Carpenters may hammer a nail and make it look easy. A novice may think it's easy, but will either bend the nail, smash their thumb or put the nail in the wrong place. End of detour.

Notice he talks about particle effects. Not being a scientist, I'd guess this means it's not about individual drivers, but a mass of cars behaving in a particular way, regardless of drivers. What can we do with this information? The same thing scientists do with hydrodynamics I suppose. Learn how particles/molecules behave moving through a pipe and you figure out how to make it go smoother.

MoonCake, the article wasn't talking about accidents clogging up traffic. It was about jams for no apparent reason.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
As someone who commutes 150 kms every day, I believe this research - however obvious it seems - is useful. When were drive on straight areas, it doesn't matter if there is 10 cars or 100 cars: the flow of traffic remains constant. If you throw in a distraction like police lights on the opposite side, or a change in the road like a sudden curve (even a slight one), the affect of a single person braking radically alters the speed of each successive car. The flow moves like boa, stretching until it hits a bend and than contracting until it makes it around the bend. One panicky, brake-happy driver on an unfamiliar road can drop my speed from 100 km to 70 km in seconds - and thus, every car behind and beside me; add to that the lane changers, who double the volume of fast lanes in seconds, and you have massive slow-downs with or without more cars.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 15 comments




Email This Post to a Friend
"Traffic Jams are Caused by ... Too Many Cars on the Road!"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More