E-Mail Post To A Friend
Email a copy of 'Enigma of the Amigara Fault' to a friend
Loading ...
44 comments to "Enigma of the Amigara Fault"
-
peach
December 10th, 2007 at
7:05 am
I read 32 pages and then it ended!! Just as something was coming out the other side of the mountain. What happened ? Where is the rest of the story?
-
fz
December 10th, 2007 at
7:23 am
NOW I’M PISSED OFF
-
DoorFrame
December 10th, 2007 at
8:06 am
I liked the ending! Did you not follow it?
-
marcus
December 10th, 2007 at
8:35 am
whoa.
ok…
that’s the reason y i don’t like horror manga… too much sentinentality.
it’s cliche, but, “curiosity killed the cat” is wat i found here. -
Willo the Wisp
December 10th, 2007 at
8:35 am
Peach, that _was_ the ending. Who needs to know more? It is an enigma, after all. And a pretty scary one I must say!
Good find, good post.
-
A Noun (is a person place or thing)
December 10th, 2007 at
9:12 am
Spooky! But felt unfinished.
-
stacyj
December 10th, 2007 at
10:08 am
Man, I remember reading this a few months ago, “creepy” is -definitely- the right word for it … Good stuff.
-
Strawberry
December 10th, 2007 at
11:01 am
I really liked it! Does anyone know where I can find more stuff like this?
-
Namowal
December 10th, 2007 at
11:20 am
I thought it was cool, but wanted more explanation as to what was going on. Who put the holes there? Why were people compelled to go in them? For example, what if they turned out to be aliens or changelings who were instinctively drawn to the holes so they could pupate into their true forms?
-
Bill
December 10th, 2007 at
11:23 am
People stay alive in there for months with no food or water? Nobody’s scared of a rubber man that will just fall over when it comes out of the hole. Good idea, just a lame ending.
-
MidwestMedic
December 10th, 2007 at
11:39 am
I liked this…less is more on the explination. A lot like old Twilight Zone and Outer Limits shows. Things do not need explaining…it’s more about the tension and feelings of those in the story.
I’m not sure of the changeling idea, though possible. I think it’s possible they are near dead people mutilated through the experience. The real mystery is how the personalized holes got there and why. But, again the greatness in the story comes from NOT explaining this.
-
zombiefodder
December 10th, 2007 at
12:04 pm
Same Hat Same Hat had a link to a funny parody of this story awhile back.
http://samehat.blogspot.com/2007/06/ito-parody-enigma-of-squarepants-f ault.html -
thomas
December 10th, 2007 at
12:08 pm
The last page was unnecessary…
-
Sergio Eidi
December 10th, 2007 at
1:24 pm
The last page was unnecessary, but added a “OMG” factor just for the illustration of the guy almost coming out - and alive.
The story is GREAT, and I agree with MidwestMedic. It´s a lot like Twilight Zone stories. No explanation is needed. The “ENIGMA” is all you really want to know about.
I just think the autor kinda spoiled the purposes of the holes on the guy´s dreams. From that, you easily guess what will happen with those poor guys.
-
Victoria
December 10th, 2007 at
1:30 pm
I’ve been a huge fan of Junji Ito’s work ever since I read UZUMAKI… if there are any online postings of stories from MUSEUM OF TERROR that would be great to share those!
-
cuimhne
December 10th, 2007 at
1:48 pm
I liked it
Very good and just the right amount of spooky. -
Chris
December 10th, 2007 at
1:59 pm
Call me simple, but I didn’t like it the same way I didn’t like Hitchcock Birds. No conventional ending.
Good idea though. Would like to read part 2
-
Aristocrates
December 10th, 2007 at
2:00 pm
I didn’t get the impression that the victims lived for more than a day or so into the holes, rather that some property of the holes pushed the bodies through all the way.
-
PotatoCouch
December 10th, 2007 at
2:32 pm
Junji Ito is great, he is very good with those types of endings. I recommend Uzumaki, as someone else mentioned. An earlier work of his, Kyrie is also good, but not as polished as Uzumaki (it’s only three books).
-
ruby
December 10th, 2007 at
2:59 pm
Loved it! Terrific! I grew up on Twilight Zone, Outer Limits, Hitchcock! The ending does not need explaining. But your imagination does need let off it’s rein for a bit.
There is no part two….that was the end! Sooooo Good!
Thank you!
-
Chrisfabo
December 10th, 2007 at
4:23 pm
…..okay, I’m actually having the problem that I’m picturing the experience from the first-person view. Damn, this is NOT a good thing. I need a unicorn chaser supreme ASAP. o.o;;;;;
-
Another Jake
December 10th, 2007 at
4:37 pm
That was twisted. Pun intended. A little too far-fetched for me though. You’d die pretty freakin early in the process.
-
chanchan
December 10th, 2007 at
4:39 pm
THIS HOLE– IT WAS MADE FOR ME!
DRR DRR DRR
-
Klink-O
December 10th, 2007 at
4:41 pm
Ohhhhhh! I went in on the wrong side!
-
Nora
December 10th, 2007 at
5:46 pm
mmm i liked it, could have been better. So basicly non-magical holes cut out in ancient times by cave people as a punishment for other cave people. The reason dosn’t explain why someone would be compelled-beyond-reason to enter.
throw ye ol logical brain factor in, and anyone would come to the conclusion that if you were a chubby person, you’d need only wait till you dropped some weight (provided you had water) to get back out.
Also why would anyone deform themselves. Wouldn’t they stop when it started to hurt, and instead start wailing for help?
-
Emperor
December 10th, 2007 at
6:03 pm
I think it worked nicely. Junji Ito manages to combine vertigo and claustrophobia which is an unsettling combination.
I find it interesting that people think the last page is unnecessary as I thought the sequence on page 26 (and the end of 25). The last page worked well, as did the first dream, but the second one possibly provides too much of a hint about the ending - I’d have preferred it to be more misdirection because once you see the oddly shaped holes on the penultimate page it rather spoils the final panel. Also “It’s slowly coming this way” rather spoils the sense of imminent dread, as you’d expect a reply like, “well I suppose we should think about getting away in the next day or so!!” That said they are minor niggles in an effective tale.
Those looking for more should read Uzumaki (and watch the film as it works well too) and Gyo. Info:
-
Joe
December 10th, 2007 at
6:09 pm
Is this a ‘pirated’ scan of the story or is it done with permission of the author or publisher?
It’s a great read, but I’m not a big fan of promoting copyright violation, despite the fact that this scan has exposed a great talent to a lot of of people who might never have otherwise read it.
-
Chad
December 10th, 2007 at
6:35 pm
the twilight zone reference is probably the most accurate. creepy without any logicality behind it all! awesome
-
biltmore
December 10th, 2007 at
6:49 pm
Same here victoria. Junji Ito’s “Uzumaki” is one of the best horror mangas out there. Really great stuff. I just started reading “Gyo” the other day.
-
Pudifoot
December 10th, 2007 at
7:28 pm
chad: it is more like the outer limits. at least in my opinion.
-
ted
December 10th, 2007 at
8:05 pm
Funnier than it is horrifying.
Amusing how some folks want everything explained. Just use your imagination. It’s not necessarily a cave-person punishment thing - that was his dream. The dream spoils the ending, by the way. You’re not surprised by the last page at all.
-
Louisa
December 10th, 2007 at
9:21 pm
That could have been so much better.
-
Carl Huber
December 10th, 2007 at
9:44 pm
Wow you guys are so over-analyzing this. Maybe the only magical properties of the area is that it can keep people alive for months. Who cares? It’s definitely a Twilight Zone thing. I thought it was neat.
-
NiteWhite
December 10th, 2007 at
9:58 pm
WHAT A WASTE OF FIVE MINUTES - I’LL NEVER GET THOSE PRECIOUS MINUTES BACK.
-
kid_icarus
December 10th, 2007 at
11:19 pm
i was thinking of this on the way home tonight, and i think the whole thing about the person shaped holes is an allegory. i think, that we do this to ourselves on an unconcious level throughout our lives.
for instance, you do something wrong, you know it’s wrong and you feel guilty about what you’ve done. you continue to punish yourself (either conciously or not) until the view of yourself becomes grotesque and disfigured. well….something like that. i think you get the gist.
either that or the holes make bananas. i never said it was a good theory.
-
Vonskippy
December 10th, 2007 at
11:40 pm
That was the DUMBEST thing I’ve ever wasted my time reading.
With such great prose like “We’re all looking for our holes” I should have known better to continue reading.
-
MoonCake
December 11th, 2007 at
7:07 am
@carl- agreed.
keep in mind, people, that this is a comic. i haven’t read any manga, but this one would definitely make me want to read more. it was interesting and gruesome. just imagine if this actually happened… what would YOU have said if you were on the other side observing the mangled gross bodies coming out? eww.. it’s like old chinese feet-binding… slow and painful…
-
Rich
December 11th, 2007 at
10:48 am
meh…
It had some really good elements, enough to keep me reading to the end. Reminded me of classic comics like Strange Tales, Tales from the Crypt and Strange Worlds… but not as fully developed.
-
jack.wh
December 11th, 2007 at
12:02 pm
Wow and the like! I enjoyed that, I thought the ending worked perfectly.
-
Ademyr
December 11th, 2007 at
2:44 pm
Really good !! nice post..
-
Tom
December 11th, 2007 at
6:52 pm
Keep in mind that this is a translation, so you should be a little forgiving of the prose. Translating from Japanese is very difficult.
For another good short, read his short story, “The Central Pillar”. It’s a great allegory on the stress placed on the breadwinner by Japanese society.
All of Ito’s work that I know of has been listed here except for Tomie, which is about an immortal girl that is repeatedly killed by men she has driven insane.
-
89
January 16th, 2008 at
8:24 am
Yeah the dream totally spoils it, even if it might have been misdirection. I doubt that the author intended that - if he misdirected, it should have been how they arrived in some kind of good place and the holes were there because they had been selected to form a perfect society or something.
I found it pretty funny though. Dance Dance Revolution.@kid_icarus
Yes, in addtion to that, just entering the holes could represent how we sometimes do bad things or surrender ourselves to a “destiny” that we don’t want but become fixated on. -
Uchiha
March 21st, 2008 at
11:56 pm
I’m not sure if the body pictured in the last panel was meant to be dead or alive… “DRR DRR DRR” could’ve just been the noise of its flesh scraping against the cave walls.
Actually, I’m not sure which is creepier. Trapped in a deforming hole for months (but somehow alive at the end), or dying trapped in there and your deformed corpse emerges.
And as for the dream, it did kind of spoil it - it made the end just a “shock horror image” rather than an expected “twist” (excuse the pun). Perhaps if in the dream, the holes remained in shape and you eventually emerged fine; but due to the effects of the quake, the holes (and its travellers) ended up as something else entirely.
In any case, I still found it amusing/creepy. And I’d probably default towards assuming they’re still alive, simply because “DRR DRR DRR” is a very funny sound for any living thing to make. Go ahead, say it.
DRR DRR DRR
-
HeroicStyle
June 8th, 2008 at
4:17 pm
I think this manga played to our most basic of narcissisms, and the fact that we all want somewhere to belong. The fact that it destroyed them was in the writers dark point of view.
For those of you wondering about the people reaction inside the tunnels. The tunnels were at an angle sloping down inside the mountain. So no matter how hard you struggled you had no choice but to move forward. Also the extremely tight fit, combined with your inability to control your movement would trigger your bodies survival instincts of intense fear and loss of all logic.
I still understand that the premise of this story makes little or no sense, but I’m trying to explain that the reactions once inside the tunnel are quite realistic. But there is no way you could ever get me inside one of those things, regardless of how much it looked like me.
Want your own avatar? Get one for free at Gravatar!
